Intro

Choosing the right ATCS sponge ball is the key to keeping condenser and chiller tubes clean, stable, and energy-efficient. The correct surface type, hardness, and dosing strategy must match the actual fouling mode (biofilm, slime, early scale) and the tube geometry inside your system.

In this guide, you’ll learn a simple and reliable selection framework:

1. start with tube I.D. fit,
2. choose the right surface type,
3. match the correct hardness,
4. finalize the dosing plan using KPI feedback.

Before you choose any ball, read the ATCS overview:
https://www.kinsoe.com/atcs-sponge-ball-cleaning/
And size correctly using:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-sizing-guide/

Start with Fit — Tube I.D. & Passability

Before selecting surface type, hardness, or dosing frequency, the first and most critical step is ensuring the ball fits the tube correctly. ATCS systems operate within tight tolerances, and even a 1–2 mm mismatch can cause:

• Poor wiping
• Ball carryover (escaping strainers)
• Sticking inside support plates
• Inconsistent cleaning performance
• Premature shrinkage or wear

Here’s how to get the fit right.

1. Measure the Actual Tube I.D. (Not Nominal Size)

ATCS tubes vary by:

• Tube material (copper, titanium, cu-ni, stainless steel)
• Wall thickness
• Age and wear
• Scaling or corrosion on the inner surface

Always measure actual internal diameter, not nameplate data.

A 19 mm nominal tube may actually measure 18.5–19.3 mm, and this variation matters for oversize selection.

2. Check the Geometry Around the Tube Bundle

Inspect:

• Support plates / baffles
• Bend transitions (if any)
• Tube-sheet entry clearance
• Strainer and mesh size for ball recapture

Any tight-area restriction requires a softer ball or a slightly adjusted diameter to prevent stalling or slow returns.

3. Oversize Window for ATCS Balls

Because ATCS operates continuously, oversize must be precise:

• Soft balls: +1.0 to +1.5 mm over actual I.D.
• Medium balls: +0.5 to +1.0 mm
• Hard balls: +0.3 to +0.7 mm (use carefully)

ATCS oversizing is much tighter than concrete pipeline sizing.

Oversize rules reference:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-sizing-guide/

4. Passability Comes Before Aggressiveness

Even the “perfect” surface type is useless if the ball doesn’t:

• Pass through every tube
• Return reliably to the strainer
• Maintain steady speed
• Avoid lodging at support plates

This is why ATCS selection always starts with fit first, then surface + hardness.

5. If Hang-Ups Occur…

Check:

• Diameter too large
• Hardness too high
• Tube geometry too tight
• Ball swelling (chemical or thermal)
• Tube-sheet alignment issues

Troubleshooting reference:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-troubleshooting/

Pick the Surface Type (Match to Fouling)

The surface finish of an ATCS sponge ball determines how effectively it removes biofilm, slime, or early mineral scale from condenser tubes. Choosing the right surface type is the fastest way to stabilize approach temperature (ΔT) and maintain chiller efficiency (kW/ton or COP).

Below is a clear, fouling-based guide.

1. Smooth Surface Balls

Best for:

• Light biofilm
• Organic slime in clean water systems
• Daily, high-frequency cleaning

How they work:
Smooth balls provide gentle, consistent wiping that prevents biofilm from maturing into soft scale. They also minimize tube stress and ball wear.

Advantages:

• Long cycle life
• Minimal risk of sticking
• Safe default choice for new ATCS setups

When to use:
Start here for any ATCS system unless fouling data shows clear evidence of slime or early scale.

2. Fine-Ridged / Grooved Balls

Best for:

• Biofilm + early slime
• Initial soft scale in cooling-tower or seawater systems
• Systems with seasonal fouling fluctuations

How they work:
Ridges increase shear force without being abrasive. They contact more micro-surface area and break up slime films more effectively than smooth balls.

Advantages:

• Stronger wiping
• Safer than abrasive rings
• Good middle-ground for medium fouling conditions

Recommended for:
Cooling tower chillers, river water, brackish water, and lightly scaling environments.

3. Abrasive-Ring / Coated Balls

Best for:

• Incipient (early-stage) mineral scaling
• Heat exchangers with slight CaCO₃ or Mg(OH)₂ deposition
• Systems experiencing periodic scaling despite chemical treatment

How they work:
A thin abrasive ring adds cutting force to remove soft crystallized deposits. These must be used carefully to avoid metal wear.

Warnings:

• Never use as a 24/7 ball type
• Not suitable for thin or delicate tubing
• Verify metallurgy compatibility (Cu/Ni/Ti/SS)

How to apply safely:
Use in short, controlled dosing bursts, then switch back to smooth or fine-ridged balls.

Important Note — Start Conservative, Then Escalate

Always begin with smooth or fine-ridged, then monitor KPIs.
Upgrade surface type only when:

• ΔT begins trending upward
• Cleaning cycles leave light residue
• Fouling accumulates faster than expected

Surface upgrade must be driven by data, not guesswork.

Wear/Life Considerations

Surface type affects service lifespan:

• Smooth → longest life
• Fine-ridged → moderate life
• Abrasive ring → short-term use (highest wear)

Life expectancy details:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-temperature-reuse/

Choose Hardness (Soft / Medium / Hard)

Hardness determines how firmly a sponge ball wipes the tube wall and how reliably it passes through support plates, tube-sheet entries, and tight-clearance points.
In ATCS systems—where tubes have very small tolerances—matching hardness to geometry and fouling type is essential.

Below is a practical guide.

Soft Hardness (Default for Most Systems)

Best for:

• New ATCS installations
• Tight tube tolerances
• Older tubes with minor imperfections
• Systems with biofilm or light slime

Why choose it:
Soft balls compress easily, making them the safest option for:

• Ensuring smooth pass-through
• Preventing hang-ups
• Avoiding tube stress
• Maintaining steady velocity

When soft is ideal:
If your system has never used ATCS before, start with soft until you understand tube behavior and fouling patterns.

Medium Hardness (More Aggressive Cleaning)

Best for:

• Slime buildup
• Early soft scale
• Stable, smooth tube bundles
• Cooling-tower or seawater chillers

Why choose it:
Medium hardness increases wiping pressure without significantly increasing the risk of hang-ups—provided geometry is smooth and oversize is controlled.

Cautions:

• Requires accurate diameter selection (+0.5 to +1.0 mm oversize)
• Monitor approach temperature (ΔT) for improvement
• If balls slow down significantly, downgrade to soft

Hard Hardness (Targeted Use Only)

Best for:

• Early mineral scaling where ridged/abrasive balls need support
• Very smooth tubing with verified passability
• Short-term corrective cycles

Why choose it:
Hard balls apply the highest wiping force, but also carry the highest sticking risk.

Important:
Hard balls must always use minimal oversize, typically +0.3 to +0.7 mm.

Do NOT use hard hardness when:

• Tube geometry has unknown clearances
• Support plates are worn or misaligned
• Tube-sheet entries show erosion
• Fouling is mostly biofilm or slime
• You need 24/7 continuous cleaning

Hard hardness is a tool, not a baseline.

Hardness + Oversize Interaction

• Harder balls → smaller oversize margin
• Softer balls → larger safe oversize window

This is critical because small oversize errors dramatically affect ATCS performance.

Quick guideline:

• Soft: +1.0 to +1.5 mm
• Medium: +0.5 to +1.0 mm
• Hard: +0.3 to +0.7 mm

Sizing reference:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-sizing-guide/

Troubleshooting Hardness Mismatches

If balls show any of the following:

• Slowing down
• Stalling at support plates
• Exiting too clean
• Not returning consistently
• Tube pressure drop rising
• ΔT climbing

→ Hardness is likely too high.

Troubleshooting guide:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-troubleshooting/

Material & Cell Structure (Snapshot)

While surface type and hardness determine wiping strength, the material and cell structure determine how the ball behaves under continuous ATCS cycling—its compression pattern, water absorption, shape retention, and long-term durability.
Choosing the right combination ensures stable performance across thousands of circulation cycles.

Closed-Cell (Most Common for ATCS)

Best for:

• Smooth condenser/chiller tubes
• Consistent wiping pressure
• Long-cycle ATCS operation
• Systems with warm or variable water temperature

Why choose it:
Closed-cell balls absorb almost no water, maintain density, and retain diameter well over time. This makes them ideal for:

• Predictable compression
• Stable oversize
• Long-term energy-efficiency stability

Key advantages:

• Low absorption → no swelling
• Longer cycle life
• Consistent wiping force

Typical use:
99% of ATCS systems start with closed-cell balls.

Fine Open-Cell (Special-Case Option)

Best for:

• Slightly rougher tubes
• Systems that need more conformity
• Light slime with slight surface unevenness

Why choose it:
Fine open-cell balls compress and adapt more to micro-irregularities. They’re rarely used as a baseline but can solve:

• Light skipping
• Poor wiping on tubes with subtle surface wear
• Early fouling in mixed-water systems

Caution:
They absorb more water → slight changes in weight and density over time.

Replacement frequency:
More frequent than closed-cell.

Material Choices — Rubber vs. PU

Rubber (Closed-Cell or Fine Open-Cell)

Best for:

• Systems with tight tube clearances
• Complex geometries
• Situations where smooth passability is critical

Advantages:

• Softer initial compression
• Excellent pass-through reliability
• Good rebound over temperature cycles

Rubber is generally the safer choice when tube condition is unknown.

Polyurethane (PU)

Best for:

• High-fouling water systems
• Environments with abrasive fines
• Operators seeking long lifespan per ball

Advantages:

• Highest abrasion resistance
• Best long-term shape retention
• Ideal for heavy-duty or high-cycle systems

Caution:
PU can feel firmer at equal hardness levels → must be sized more precisely.

Material & hardness reference:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-materials-hardness/

Which Should You Choose? (Quick Rule)

• Choose closed-cell rubber for top passability and steady wiping.
• Choose PU closed-cell for maximum durability in abrasive or high-fouling ATCS systems.
• Consider fine open-cell only if tubes are slightly worn or if skipping persists even after adjusting oversize and hardness.

Build the Dosing Plan

Once you’ve selected the surface type, hardness, and material, the next step is setting up a dosing plan that matches your fouling rate, tube geometry, and chiller load.
ATCS performs best when dosing is consistent, data-driven, and responsive to system KPIs—not guessed.

Below is a practical, field-proven framework.

1. Define the Core Dosing Variables

Every ATCS system relies on three main settings:

① Balls per tube (BPT)

Typical starting point:
1 ball per tube for smooth-surface balls
1.1–1.3 per tube for fine-ridged
0.8–1.0 per tube for abrasive-ring (short-term use)

This ensures enough wiping pressure without overwhelming the strainer.

② Circulation frequency (Cycles per hour)

ATCS vendors commonly recommend:

• 2–6 cycles per hour for smooth and fine-ridged balls
• 1–2 cycles per hour for abrasive-ring balls (only during corrective cleaning)

More aggressive fouling → more frequent cycles.

③ On/Off timing relative to load

During:

• High load → increase dosing frequency
• Low load or cold water → reduce dosing (lower fouling rate)
• Startup or post-maintenance → use soft/smooth balls at gentle frequency

2. Starting Heuristics (Reliable Defaults)

For most cooling-tower or seawater chillers:

• Surface: Fine-ridged
• Hardness: Soft or Medium
• Cycles/hour: 3–4
• Balls/tube: ~1.1

For clean water systems:

• Surface: Smooth
• Hardness: Soft
• Cycles/hour: 2–3
• Balls/tube: 1

For chillers with early mineral scaling:

• Surface: Abrasive ring (short-term)
• Hardness: Medium
• Cycles/hour: 1–2 for 1–3 days
  Then return to smooth or fine-ridged balls.

3. Adjust Dosing Based on KPI Feedback

KPIs determine whether you need:

• Higher dosing
• Lower dosing
• New hardness
• More aggressive surface
• A different oversize

Key KPIs to watch:

1. Approach Temperature (ΔT)

If ΔT steadily rises → increase cycles OR upgrade surface.

2. kW/ton (COP / energy efficiency)

If your chiller needs more power to deliver the same cooling → wiping is insufficient.

3. Pressure Drop (ΔP) Across the Bundle

If ΔP increases → fouling or sticking.
Check ball size, hardness, or tube restrictions.

4. Capture Count (Ball Return Rate)

If balls aren’t returning consistently → size/hardness mismatch or dosing too aggressive.

Troubleshooting guide:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-troubleshooting/

4. Example Scenarios

A. Seawater Condenser (High Biofouling)

• Surface: Fine-ridged
• Hardness: Soft/Medium
• Cycles: 4–6/hour
• Balls/tube: 1.1–1.2
• KPIs tracked: ΔT stability + capture rate

B. Cooling Tower Chiller (Slime + Soft Scale)

• Surface: Fine-ridged
• Hardness: Medium
• Cycles: 3–4/hour
• Balls/tube: 1.1 per tube

C. Clean Water Chiller (Low Fouling)

• Surface: Smooth
• Hardness: Soft
• Cycles: 2–3/hour
• Balls/tube: 1 per tube

D. Corrective Cleaning for Early Scale

• Surface: Abrasive ring
• Hardness: Medium
• Cycles: 1–2/hour, but for limited hours/days only
• Then switch back to smooth/fine-ridged

ATCS overview for context:
https://www.kinsoe.com/atcs-sponge-ball-cleaning/

Monitoring & Optimization

An ATCS system performs best when it is continuously monitored and periodically adjusted. Water quality changes seasonally, fouling patterns shift, and tube conditions evolve—so your surface type, hardness, and dosing frequency must be optimized based on real data, not set once and forgotten.

Below is a practical, industry-friendly framework for keeping your ATCS system stable, efficient, and predictable.

1. Monitor the Three Core KPIs

① Approach Temperature (ΔT) — The Primary Performance Indicator

ΔT provides the clearest picture of how clean your tubes are.

• ΔT rising → fouling is building up; increase dosing frequency or upgrade surface type.
• ΔT stable or decreasing → system is cleaning effectively; you may safely reduce dosing to extend ball life.
• ΔT fluctuating → inconsistent ball movement or capture issues; check hardness, size, and strainer performance.

ΔT should always be the first KPI you check.

② kW/ton (or COP) — Energy Efficiency Indicator

If your chiller consumes more power to produce the same cooling:

• Wiping pressure may be insufficient
• Dosing frequency may be too low
• The ball surface type or hardness may be mismatched to the fouling type

Energy efficiency typically begins to decline before fouling becomes visible, making this a valuable early-warning KPI.

③ Pressure Drop (ΔP) Across the Tube Bundle

A rising ΔP indicates:

• Balls slowing or stalling
• Partial tube obstruction
• Support plate hang-ups
• Inconsistent ball return
• Fouling accumulating in specific areas

A stable ΔP confirms smooth ball passage and healthy fouling control.

2. Seasonal and Operational Optimization

Cooling-Tower Water (Seasonal Fouling)

Summer:

• Higher biofouling rate
• Use fine-ridged surface
• Increase dosing (4–6 cycles/hour)

Winter:

• Lower fouling rate
• Reduce dosing (2–3 cycles/hour)
• Smooth balls often sufficient

Seawater Systems (Biological Variation)

Seawater fouling changes dramatically across the year.

• Summer: Medium hardness + fine-ridged
• Winter: Soft hardness + smooth or fine-ridged

Closed-Loop or Clean Water Systems

Fouling is stable and minimal.

• Smooth surface, soft hardness
• Low dosing frequency
• Mainly monitor ΔT for early drift

3. Monitor Ball Condition & Capture Rate

Capture rate < 95%?

Likely causes:

• Ball diameter too small
• Hardness too high
• Shrinkage due to temperature exposure
• Strainer mesh worn or misaligned

Balls exiting too clean?

Indicates poor wiping force.
Adjust by:

• Increasing hardness
• Switching to fine-ridged surface
• Increasing oversize slightly

Balls wearing too quickly?

Possible causes:

• Rough tube geometry
• Abrasive deposits
• Over-dosing frequency

Inspect tubes and reduce dosing rate if needed.

4. Quarterly Optimization Routine

Every 2–3 months, review:

• ΔT trends
• kW/ton or COP
• Pressure drop
• Capture logs
• Ball wear condition
• Strainer and mesh condition
• Overall fouling patterns

Update the surface type, hardness, or dosing frequency based on observed data. This proactive approach drastically reduces long-term energy cost and sponge ball consumption.

5. Related Technical Guides

• ATCS Overview → https://www.kinsoe.com/atcs-sponge-ball-cleaning/
• Reuse & Temperature → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-temperature-reuse/
• Troubleshooting → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-troubleshooting/

 

ATCS Sponge Ball Selection Matrix

Fouling Type	Tube Condition	Recommended Surface Type	Hardness	Dosing Guidance
Light biofilm (clean water systems)	Smooth, new tubes	Smooth	Soft	Light & frequent: 2–3 cycles/hour
Biofilm + light slime	Smooth or slightly worn	Smooth / Fine-ridged	Soft → Medium	Moderate frequency: 3–4 cycles/hour
Slime (cooling tower, river, or seawater)	Smooth to slightly uneven	Fine-ridged	Soft/Medium	3–5 cycles/hour depending on ΔT
Soft scale (early mineral deposits)	Smooth tubes only	Fine-ridged / Abrasive ring (short-term)	Medium	Corrective dosing: 1–2 cycles/hour, limited duration
Incipient scale (visible crystals forming)	Verified smooth, clean geometry	Abrasive ring	Medium (strict oversize control)	Short bursts only (hours or days), then return to smooth
Mixed fouling (biofilm + soft scale)	Slightly rough or aged tubes	Fine-ridged	Medium	3–4 cycles/hour; monitor ΔT
Unstable return rate / inconsistent wipe	Tight clearances, older supports	Smooth	Soft	Reduce cycles; confirm fit and strainer capture
High fouling + abrasive conditions	Rougher tubes, high solids	Fine-ridged / PU variants	Medium	Frequent dosing (4–6 cycles/hour) with regular monitoring

---

How to Use This Matrix

1. Identify fouling mode (biofilm, slime, soft scale, early scale).
2. Check tube condition (smooth, slightly worn, rough).
3. Select surface type using the first two columns.
4. Match hardness based on geometry and fouling strength.
5. Apply dosing guidance and adjust based on ΔT + kW/ton + ΔP.

For deeper understanding, refer to:
ATCS Overview → https://www.kinsoe.com/atcs-sponge-ball-cleaning/
Temperature & Reuse → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-temperature-reuse/

ATCS Sponge Ball Specification Template

1. Tube Information

• Actual tube I.D.: ______ mm
• Tube material (CuNi / Copper / Ti / SS): __________________
• Tube condition (smooth / slightly worn / rough): __________________
• Support plate conditions (good / worn / unknown): __________________
• Presence of tight bends or special geometry: __________________

2. Operating Conditions

• Water source (cooling tower / seawater / river / closed loop): __________________
• Typical operating temperature range: ______ °C
• Existing fouling type (biofilm / slime / soft scale / early mineral scale): __________________
• Seasonal fouling variation (yes/no): __________________

3. Ball Selection Parameters

• Preferred surface type (smooth / fine-ridged / abrasive ring): __________________
• Hardness (soft / medium / hard): __________________
• Material (rubber / PU): __________________
• Cell structure (closed-cell / fine open-cell): __________________
• Required oversize relative to I.D.: +______ mm
• Balls per tube (BPT): ______
• Target cycles per hour: ______

4. KPI Targets

• Target approach temperature (ΔT): ______ °C
• Max acceptable ΔT drift before adjustment: ______ °C
• Acceptable pressure drop (ΔP) range: ______ kPa
• Minimum capture rate: ______ %

5. Maintenance & Monitoring Notes

• Ball inspection interval: daily / weekly / monthly
• Dosing adjustments planned: seasonal / quarterly
• Shut-down or cleaning notes (if applicable): __________________

---

FAQ

1. How aggressive should I go on day one?

Start conservative.
Use smooth or fine-ridged balls with soft hardness, then observe ΔT, kW/ton, and capture rate.
Escalate only if fouling indicators don’t stabilize.
Early over-aggressiveness can cause unnecessary wear or ball stalling.

2. What if balls escape the strainer?

This is usually a fit or hardness issue.
Check the following:

• Ball diameter too small
• Ball has shrunk due to heat exposure
• Hardness too high → passes through mesh too quickly
• Strainer mesh damaged or worn
• Flow velocity too high

If balls escape repeatedly, size up by 0.5–1.0 mm or switch to softer hardness.

More troubleshooting solutions:
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-troubleshooting/

3. Do abrasive-ring balls damage tubes?

They can—if used incorrectly.
Abrasive-ring balls should only be used:

• On smooth, verified geometries
• With tube metallurgy that can tolerate micro-abrasion
• In short, controlled dosing bursts
• Under close monitoring of ΔT and ΔP

They are not meant for continuous use.
Once scale is reduced, switch back to smooth or fine-ridged balls immediately.

Conclusion

Choosing the right surface type, hardness, oversize, and dosing frequency can dramatically improve ATCS performance, stabilize ΔT, reduce energy consumption, and extend tube life.
If you want a precise, system-specific recommendation, we can help.

Share the details below for a tailored selection plan:

• Tube I.D. and material (CuNi / Copper / Ti / SS)
• Water source (cooling tower / seawater / river / closed loop)
• Fouling type (biofilm, slime, soft scale, early mineral scale)
• Current ball material, hardness, and surface type
• Operating temperature range
• Desired KPIs: target ΔT, acceptable ΔP, capture rate
• ATCS dosing settings: cycles/hour and balls/tube

We’ll recommend the optimal ball size + surface type + hardness + dosing strategy for your exact system.

Explore Our High-Quality ATCS Sponge Balls

👉 Sponge Cleaning Balls (Kinsoe Rubber)
https://www.kinsoe.com/product/rubber-sponge-cleaning-balls/

👉 Sponge Cleaning Balls: Fast Buyer’s Guide
https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-cleaning-balls-fast-buyers-guide/

Additional Technical Resources

• ATCS Overview → https://www.kinsoe.com/atcs-sponge-ball-cleaning/
• Sizing Guide → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-sizing-guide/
• Materials & Hardness → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-materials-hardness/
• Temperature & Reuse → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-temperature-reuse/
• Troubleshooting → https://www.kinsoe.com/sponge-ball-troubleshooting/