Silicone vs. Rubber: What’s the Difference and Which One Should You Use?

Introduction

Did you know that over 60% of non-specialists can’t accurately tell the difference between silicone and rubber when making material choices? I’ve seen this firsthand—at trade shows, in client emails, and even in product development meetings. People often treat them as interchangeable, leading to poor performance, higher returns, or even product recalls.

Picture this: a food equipment designer unknowingly specifies standard rubber seals instead of food-grade silicone for high-temperature steam applications. The result? Warped gaskets, regulatory compliance failures, and an expensive recall. Or a procurement officer chooses silicone tubing over NBR for oil transfer—only to discover rapid degradation and customer complaints.

These aren’t just isolated cases. The confusion between silicone and rubber costs companies money and puts product reputations at risk.

That’s why I wrote this article—to help clarify the key differences, uses, and decision-making logic between the two materials. Whether you’re a product designer, procurement manager, or just trying to choose the safest baby bottle nipple, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know.

What Are Silicone and Rubber?

Understanding the core differences between silicone and rubber starts with their origin and molecular makeup. While both are classified as elastomers—materials with elastic properties—they are fundamentally different in structure, performance, and application scope.

Rubber: Natural and Synthetic Origins

Rubber, in its broadest sense, can be either natural or synthetic. Natural rubber is harvested from the latex of rubber trees, while synthetic variants are created through polymerization of petroleum-based monomers. Common synthetic rubbers include:

• NBR (Nitrile Butadiene Rubber) – excellent oil resistance, used in automotive and industrial seals.
• EPDM (Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer) – superb UV and ozone resistance, ideal for outdoor and roofing applications.
• CR (Neoprene) – good weather and flame resistance, often used in protective gear and adhesives.
• SBR (Styrene-Butadiene Rubber) – a general-purpose rubber often found in tires and footwear.

Despite their differences, these rubbers share certain common traits: good mechanical strength, elasticity, cost-effectiveness, and customization flexibility. However, their performance can vary significantly depending on chemical composition.

Rubber’s biggest advantage lies in its wide availability and balance of properties, but its temperature resistance and long-term aging performance can be limiting.

Silicone: A Synthetic Elastomer

Unlike carbon-based rubbers, silicone is made from a silicon-oxygen backbone, derived from silica (sand). This fundamental difference gives silicone some unique properties not found in traditional rubbers.

• Extreme temperature resistance: -60°C to +230°C (and even higher for some formulations)
• Outstanding UV, ozone, and weather resistance
• Biocompatibility: safe for medical, food, and baby care applications
• Low toxicity and inertness: does not support microbial growth or react with most chemicals

However, silicone tends to have lower tensile strength and tear resistance compared to rubber. It’s also more expensive and not ideal for oil-intensive environments.

In short: Rubber is diverse, strong, and economical. Silicone is specialized, clean, and heat-resistant.

Why People Confuse the Two

It’s easy to see why people mix up silicone and rubber—they look, feel, and behave similarly in many everyday situations. But beneath the surface, they’re quite different.

First, both materials share softness, flexibility, and stretchability. Whether you’re handling a silicone baking mat or a rubber tire valve, the tactile experience is similar: elastic, durable, and slightly grippy. This physical resemblance reinforces the misconception that they are the same material.

Second, in casual conversation and even in product labeling, both are often lumped together under the broad term “rubber” or “elastomer.” For example, a baby pacifier might be labeled “made from safe rubber,” even though it’s silicone. In industrial catalogs, “rubber gaskets” might include EPDM, NBR, or silicone variants—further blurring the lines for buyers and engineers alike.

To make things even more confusing, some silicone products are marketed as “synthetic rubber,” which is technically true—but misleading if the buyer doesn’t understand the structural differences. This creates problems when a product is selected based on price or availability rather than performance characteristics.

This confusion isn’t harmless. Choosing the wrong material can lead to product failure, health risks, or unnecessary cost. That’s why clarity matters—not just in technical specs, but in how we communicate and compare these materials.

Key Differences Between Silicone and Rubber

Now that we’ve explored user needs, let’s directly compare silicone and rubber across critical performance dimensions. I’ve laid out the most practical distinctions in the table below, based on both material science and field experience.

Some insights:

• For high-heat, UV-exposed, or medical applications, silicone outperforms rubber almost every time.
• For applications needing toughness, oil resistance, or lower cost, rubber may be the better choice.
• Material selection is always a trade-off. What matters is matching the properties to your specific application—not defaulting to what’s familiar or cheaper.

This table simplifies a complex topic—but it gives you a clear starting point.

When to Use Silicone or Rubber

When I advise clients on material selection, I always say: don’t choose based on the name—choose based on the job. Here’s a breakdown of real-world use cases that illustrates when silicone or rubber makes more sense:

• Oven mitts, baking molds, air fryer gaskets → Silicone
  Silicone can handle high temperatures without deforming, leaching chemicals, or becoming brittle. That’s why it dominates the kitchenware and cookware category, especially when food safety and dishwasher resistance are required.
• Automotive seals, tires, engine mounts → Rubber (e.g., NBR, EPDM, SBR)
  These parts face continuous mechanical stress, oil exposure, and a need for rugged elasticity. Synthetic rubbers like NBR and EPDM offer high resistance to fuel, oil, vibration, and abrasion—making them the obvious choice for vehicles.
• Medical tubing, catheters, cleanroom seals → Silicone
  Medical-grade silicone is non-reactive, biocompatible, and can be sterilized repeatedly. That’s why it’s trusted in hospitals, labs, and pharmaceutical manufacturing. It’s also odorless and inert—key traits for sensitive environments.
• Industrial gaskets and seals → It depends
  For sealing in chemical plants, factories, or electrical equipment, material choice hinges on:
  • Heat exposure → Silicone wins
  • Oil/chemical contact → Rubber (like FKM or NBR) wins
  • UV/outdoor conditions → EPDM or Silicone, depending on mechanical load
  • Cost-sensitive projects → Rubber is often preferred

This use-case perspective is crucial. Silicone isn’t always better. Rubber isn’t always cheaper. What matters is application fit.

How to Choose

If you’re still unsure whether to go with silicone or rubber, you’re not alone. Even experienced engineers sometimes need to weigh multiple factors before making a final call. That’s why I’ve developed a simple 4-step framework to guide the decision-making process.

Step 1: Evaluate the Environment

Ask yourself: What conditions will this material face?

• High heat (above 150°C)? → Go with silicone
• Constant UV or outdoor exposure? → Silicone or EPDM rubber
• Exposure to oil, fuel, or grease? → Choose NBR, FKM, or other oil-resistant rubbers
• High mechanical stress or abrasion? → Rubber often performs better

Step 2: Check Safety and Regulatory Requirements

Different applications come with different rules.

• Food contact? → Use FDA-approved silicone
• Medical or cleanroom? → Only USP Class VI silicone
• Electrical insulation? → Silicone and EPDM are both valid options, depending on voltage and temperature
• Flame-retardant applications? → Ensure proper formulation, often available in both families

Step 3: Assess Mechanical Demands

• Need for high elasticity, tear strength, or impact resistance? → Rubber is usually better
• Need for flexibility over time at low or high temperatures? → Silicone maintains its properties better
• Need to compress and seal tightly (like gaskets)? → Depends on the shape and loading, but silicone offers softer compression

Step 4: Factor in Budget and Supply Chain

• Is cost a major constraint? → Rubber is more economical
• Looking for long-term value with fewer replacements? → Silicone may justify the higher price
• Need local availability or short lead times? → Rubber compounds are generally easier to source in bulk

Quick Tip: Always ask your supplier for test data, certification, or samples—especially for high-risk applications. Material names alone don’t tell the full story.

By following these steps, I’ve helped dozens of clients avoid costly mistakes and choose the right elastomer for their design, budget, and environment.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Even with all the technical details and comparisons, certain questions come up again and again. Here are the most common ones I’ve encountered—and the answers I always give:

When people compare silicone and rubber, they’re usually trying to solve a real-world problem: a material that fails under heat, cracks outdoors, or doesn’t meet safety standards. Over the years, I’ve answered hundreds of such inquiries—from engineers designing medical devices to consumers choosing a new spatula. Below are the most common questions I get—and how I explain the trade-offs.

Which Material Withstands High Temperatures Better?

Silicone is the clear winner for heat resistance. It stays flexible and chemically stable from -60°C up to +230°C, with some high-grade versions tolerating even more. That’s why it’s used in oven seals, baking molds, and industrial insulation.

Rubber, on the other hand, varies by type:

• EPDM: up to ~150°C
• NBR: up to ~120°C
• Natural rubber: even lower

If your application involves constant heat, open flame, or thermal cycling, silicone is the safer, longer-lasting choice.

Which Material Is Better for Outdoor or Harsh Environments?

Silicone resists aging better in sunlight, ozone, and weather. It doesn’t dry out, crack, or become brittle like many rubbers do when left outdoors. This makes it ideal for solar panel seals, outdoor lighting gaskets, or marine equipment.

Rubber’s weatherability depends on the formulation.

• EPDM: decent UV and ozone resistance
• NBR, SBR, Natural rubber: degrade quickly without additives

For long-term exposure, silicone almost always outperforms rubber in environmental durability.

Which Material Is Safer for Food or Skin Contact?

Silicone is highly trusted in sensitive environments. Food-grade silicone is certified by the FDA and can be used for baby bottles, baking sheets, and wearable skin-contact items. It’s inert, odorless, and hypoallergenic.

Rubber’s safety is more conditional. Unless it’s specifically formulated as food-safe or medical-grade, it may contain fillers, plasticizers, or sulfur-based vulcanizing agents—not suitable for ingestion or prolonged skin contact.

If the product touches the mouth, skin, or food, choose silicone unless rubber certification is clearly provided.

Which Material Offers Better Mechanical Strength?

Rubber is stronger, tougher, and more elastic. It’s better at absorbing shock, resisting tears, and withstanding repeated flexing—essential for automotive bushings, tires, and industrial dampers.

Silicone is softer and more flexible, but its mechanical properties are weaker. It can tear or deform under high loads or sharp edges.

If your part needs to withstand force, friction, or compression, rubber performs better.

Why Is Silicone More Expensive? Is the Cost Justified?

Silicone has a higher production cost due to its refined raw materials and curing process. However, its resistance to heat, UV, and chemicals often leads to longer lifespan and fewer replacements.

Rubber is cheaper upfront and works well for short-term or low-risk applications. But when maintenance downtime or replacement costs matter, silicone may prove more cost-effective over time.

It’s not just about price—it’s about total value in your specific use case.

Which Material Handles Chemicals and Oils Better?

Rubber types like NBR and FKM are specifically designed for chemical resistance:

• NBR: excellent for oils and fuels
• FKM (like Viton): outstanding resistance to solvents, acids, and chemicals

Silicone resists water, alcohols, and mild chemicals, but not strong acids, fuels, or solvents. It can swell or degrade in oily environments.

For chemical plants, fuel lines, or oil gaskets, rubber is the right call.

What’s the Right Choice for Everyday Applications?

Here’s a simple rule of thumb based on your needs:

• Choose silicone if you care about:
  • High heat resistance
  • Hygiene or food/skin safety
  • Long-term UV or outdoor exposure
• Choose rubber if you care about:
  • Oil and chemical resistance
  • Mechanical strength
  • Lower upfront cost

Is silicone a type of rubber?

Yes, silicone is technically a type of synthetic rubber, but with a very different chemical structure. While most rubbers are carbon-based, silicone is built on a silicon-oxygen backbone, which gives it unique thermal and weathering properties.

Can rubber be used instead of silicone?

It depends entirely on the application. For high-temperature, medical, or food-grade use, rubber is generally not a safe substitute. But for oil sealing, impact resistance, or mechanical durability, rubber often performs better than silicone.

Is silicone more durable than rubber?

Not always. Silicone is more durable in heat, UV, and chemical inertness, but it’s softer and weaker in mechanical strength and abrasion resistance. Durability depends on the specific stress your product will face.

Which is safer for baby products?

Silicone is the safer choice. It’s hypoallergenic, odorless, and can be manufactured in food-grade or medical-grade forms. Many rubber materials, unless explicitly certified, can contain additives that are not suitable for prolonged skin or oral contact.

Every application is different. The “right” material is the one that fits your specific performance and budget goals—not necessarily the most expensive or familiar.

Conclusion

Choosing between silicone and rubber isn’t about picking a “better” material—it’s about picking the right one for your specific needs.

Silicone shines in extreme environments, medical and food applications, and where long-term exposure to heat, UV, or chemicals is a concern. Rubber, on the other hand, offers strength, flexibility, and cost-efficiency in oil-heavy, mechanically demanding, or mass-market applications.

If there’s one takeaway, it’s this:

There is no one-size-fits-all elastomer. Know your environment. Understand your standards. Then choose wisely.

If you’re still unsure or want expert advice tailored to your product or project, I’m here to help.

Need help choosing the right elastomer for your application?
Contact us for a free consultation or request samples today.